Investigations clear New York dairy of animal abuse

 Resize text         Printer-friendly version of this article Printer-friendly version of this article reports investigations by the New York Department of Agriculture and Markets and other experts show the Willet Dairy meets or exceeds animal-care standards despite accusations by an animal-rights organization.

An undercover worker from Mercy for Animals, a Chicago-based animal-rights group, released a video showing what it called inhumane treatment of cows and calves at Willet Dairy. Results from two investigations found the dairy’s workers used care practices equal to or above industry standards. The final reports showed no systemic abuse of cattle on the farm.

The investigation was completed by state Department of Agriculture and Markets, state Cattle Health and Assurance Program, state College of Veterinary Medicine Animal Health Diagnostic Center and ProDairy.

The investigation did find one dairy worker from the video hitting a cow on the nose with a screwdriver handle. That employee, Phil Niles, pleaded guilty to animal cruelty. He was fined $350, was fired from the dairy and is denied contact with animals for a year, according to The Post-Standard.

Apart from the charge against Niles, practices on the farm kept the 5,000-cow dairy cows clean and well cared for. Some of the practices Mercy for Animals found inhumane were common and according to the district attorney’s report, “not currently illegal in New York state.”

The undercover work who released the video admitted he is not an expert on dairy operations or New York state animal-welfare laws.


Comments (2) Leave a comment 

e-Mail (required)


characters left

john lyons    
addison  |  March, 29, 2011 at 03:06 PM

too bad this is in a dairyherd editorial not front page where the original accusations were. The dairy and the industry has been dragged through the mud and again it's back page for the clearing of the dairy. Where is righteous news reporting now? If you don't understand certain business practices get informed or shut up!

Mr. Joe    
Victoria, BC  |  March, 30, 2011 at 02:15 AM

I find it difficult to imagine how 5,000 cows in one place can be adequately cared for or how anyone can know for sure how some employees of such a factory operation are working with the cows at all times. It would seem that 5,000 cows anywhere could very well be subjected to abuse especially when they are a unit of production and profit. What is glaringly salient in this post is that the inhumane practises are legal so the court is not ultimately looking at what is humane or inhumane but what is legal or illegal. Perhaps our legal practises are actually not so humane?

Massey Ferguson 5600 Series

Our most advanced multi-tasking mid-range ever. Perfect for livestock, dairy, hay, and general all-around farm work, these exceptional loader tractors ... Read More

View all Products in this segment

View All Buyers Guides

Feedback Form
Leads to Insight