Another look at when to start feeding hay

 Resize text         Printer-friendly version of this article Printer-friendly version of this article

It is an ongoing debate of dairy calf nutrition: when is the best time to start introducing forages into the diets of young calves, in terms of physiological development, cost efficiency and performance?

Researchers at the University of British Columbia led by Marina von Keyserlingk recently conducted a study to assess the carryover effects of providing forage during the milk-feeding period on postweaning feed intake and growth of heifers.

Their study, which recently was published in the Journal of Dairy Science, included 16 Holstein heifers. All heifers were fed a liquid diet of 8 L/day of whole milk from days three to 35 of life, and then gradually weaned between days 36 and 56. All heifers were provided free-choice access to water and texturized calf starter until they were moved to group housing at day 71.

Half of the heifers also were fed free-choice chopped grass hay through the same time period. This differentiation in diet was continued for one additional week in group housing, after which all animals were placed on a common diet including restricted starter and free-choice, coarsely chopped orchardgrass hay. Feed intake and growth were monitored through 18 weeks of age. Proving hay before weaning did not reduce growth of calves but did affect how calves grew.

Among the results:

  • There was no significant difference in starter dry-matter intake between the two groups.
  • Initial and final body weights were similar between the two groups.
  • Forage consumption and total dry-matter intake (starter plus hay), neutral detergent fiber, crude protein and metabolizable energy intakes were greater in heifers fed forage pre-weaning.
  • Although feed efficiency (BW gain/DM intake) after switching to a common diet was greater in calves previously fed starter alone, providing no forage before weaning resulted in calves developing larger bellies (as measured by body barrel circumference) when first provided to forage after weaning, suggesting that these animals had difficulty transitioning to forage-based diets.

 The authors concluded that providing hay earlier in life promotes forage intake when heifers are switched to a higher-forage diet, but greater feed consumption did not translate into higher bodyweight gain. They believe that higher rates of forage intake after weaning of calves fed hay early in life were due to improved rumen capacity to accommodate and digest forage, as a result of greater saliva flow to the rumen and increased ruminal pH.

While the grain-only fed calves had higher feed efficiency after weaning, the authors suggest evaluating that result with caution, because less-developed rumens in this group could have contributed to less efficient digestion and passage of forages when they were initially introduced after weaning.

Comments (3) Leave a comment 

e-Mail (required)


characters left

donna weber    
bovina venter, ny  |  August, 13, 2012 at 03:36 PM

Leonard always said you have to build that barrel when they are young so they can consume greater amounts when they become milk cows...

Colin Lotzof    
Israel  |  August, 14, 2012 at 01:28 AM

The question I always ask, is how the early Ruman development will operate as a production unit, we raise our calves to be as efficient as possible as milk producers. My solution has been to use a 21% starter, together with a mix of 25% hay and a 25% Alfalfa mix. The protein levels remain at 16%, and the calf gets enough roughage to activate ruman activity, as well as papilla development. I believe that a mix of hay and starter creates a lower protein level, and with the calfs growth rate at this age as intense as it is, the calf could possibly need to eat more mix to get enough protein intake, thus causing a barrel belly.

August, 14, 2012 at 03:38 AM

From my experience, feeding some hay will first avoid the risk of straw chewing. At some point (2-3 weeks?) the calf starts feeling the need to chew: if there is no hay, she will chew straw..and litter straw is not very clean! So I would start wih some hay strictly for behavioural needs: at first, in fact, the calf will use only milk proteins and energy to grow, since rumen is not working yet. The, when starter intake will increase, rumen will start its development: rumen papillae development is driven by starch fermentation and not by hay, unfortunately. However, hay will help increase rumen capacity. As regards hay quality, I would suggest young hay (not too lignified) and with low nitrate-content.

Biotal Forage Inoculants

"Biotal offers a range of forage inoculants proven to help win the battle to preserve feed quality and value. Call ... Read More

View all Products in this segment

View All Buyers Guides

Feedback Form
Leads to Insight