Dear Chipotle: Farmers respond to ‘scarecrow’ ad

 Resize text         Printer-friendly version of this article Printer-friendly version of this article

Chipotle is at it again.

Chipotle The company’s latest animated short film made its way around the Internet last week, earning praises from advertising critics and consumers, while angering those within the agricultural industry. According to Chipotle, the film and its coordinating game are “designed to help educate people about the world of industrial food production that supplies much of what they eat.”

To the ag community, however, the film does nothing but further mislead consumers.

“This is a well-made animated short film. Props to the marketing folks who created it. But the message is not realistic nor does it paint an accurate image of modern agriculture,” rancher and “agvocate” Ryan Goodman wrote in a blog post.

Goodman isn’t alone. The Center for Consumer Freedom (CCF) was one of the first to call Chipotle out on the video.

“There’s a larger agriculture narrative developed by city-dwellers over the years who have ideological problems with modern food technology and production,” CCF said. “Chipotle is taking advantage of it as much as possible to make money. It’s important to remember that, as one in the ag community puts it, marketing is not reality. There are plenty of videos—not cartoons—that show modern farms in a straightforward manner (that is, without the horror-movie soundtrack and editing of an animal-rights video).”

Read, “If Chipotle only had a brain…”

Other agriculturists and ag supporters have taken to Chipotle’s Facebook page to air their distaste for the ad, including:

“Sad that Chipotle is scamming all of you into believing their food is better for you. I am cool with companies labling products GMO-free, or organic... and I am cool with people choosing to buy those products and I think they should be available... but Chipotle's depiction of the treatment of farm animals is totally FALSE. Yes, there are some bad farmers out there. but there are also bad pet owners as well... I cant stand it to see dogs chained to a house, but my dairy cows all had a name and free pasture to roam and they were LOVED. 98% of the US population is totally removed from agriculture and it is so sad to see Chipotle jumping on a crazy media bandwagon misinforming people to sell their burritos.”

“I don't see the point of this ad. It turns me off on the Chipotle brand. The depiction of the food industry is so out of line with reality. Having a game that youth will play associated with it is even more deplorable. There are all ready too many misinformed consumers this will not help. It is pretty bad when you have to cut down an industry with lies to sell your product. Chipotle bashes “big,” yet the gazillions of tortillas that the company goes through aren’t exactly made in some Mexican grandmother’s kitchen. In the Pacific Northwest, Chipotle sources chips and tortillas from Don Pancho Authentic Mexican Foods, Inc., a company that brags on its website that it has “grown from a small company into a state-of-the-art processing plant.” In fact, judging from the pictures, Chipotle is sourcing food from a veritable “industrial tortilla factory.” i won't be eating at Chipotle any more.”

“Shame on chipotle! Learn what real agriculture is about!!!!!!! Your images are full of lies and misconception! What a shameful way to exploit others to magnify your profits. As an American farmer father of 4, your lies are what's going to push out country into starvation one day. But you won't care for a while.....until you run out of money that you unrightfully earned! God bless Americans! Especially those sacrificing everything so that ALL people may be fed 3 times a day”

“You're simply propagating GMO hysteria. Farmers are losing money because of people who believe these silly commercials as truth. This commercial doesn't represent where food comes from any more than a shoe box represents where shoes are made. I suggest re-thinking your ad strategy. Unless pandering to the uneducated is one of your goals.”

“I don't want to wade into the farm vs farm debate but I am going to say that I do not give my support to people and corporations that deal in negative advertising. I'm not sure why you decided to accentuate the negative when you seem so positive about what you are doing. Why not just stick to showing off your farmers and your "integrity" and let the good you are doing speak for itself? There is too much negativity and strife in our society today. Too bad you decided to add to it. I'm out!”

“I'm with you. I will not spend a single dollar at Chipotle Mexican Grill. In fact, I'm hoping the Agriculture Industry/Non-Profits sue them for false marketing and advertising. This is just plain unacceptable. And I don't even farm!”

Click here to read more or to see messages left for Chipotle.

Earlier this year, Panera Bread earned similar criticism in a campaign that referred to farmers who use antibiotics to treat their animals as “lazy.” One blogger named Dairy Carrie led the charge against the campaign, uniting the industry and even prompted the company’s chief marketing officer to call Carrie directly to discuss the campaign.

The company quickly – and quietly – removed its “Easy Chicken” digital and social media campaign following the outrage, and the company has said it does not plan to bring the campaign back.  



Comments (10) Leave a comment 

Name
e-Mail (required)
Location

Comment:

characters left

Klemens    
Germany  |  September, 17, 2013 at 09:00 AM

show this video: BASF: one hungry planet http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Jd-48Zw0Tr4

Steve Savage    
Encinitas, California  |  September, 17, 2013 at 10:10 AM

If a company or a brand has to demonize and/or lie about its competition to sell its product, it reveals something very negative about that company's products or about the character of the people involved. In many other contexts something like this Chipotle add would be considered "hate speech." Why is that "ok" here?

Leroy Rundhaug    
wisconsin  |  September, 17, 2013 at 11:43 AM

A large portion of milk is produced from cows confined on concrete, never see the sun or fresh grass,are fed and injected with hormones and fed synthetic feed is a true statement. Maybe our truth should be presented as not bad?

southern farmer    
Olar, SC  |  September, 17, 2013 at 11:57 AM

Mr. Leroy, what is truth? You state that what you say is "truth"! We are a small dairy farmer, but even on large farms, the cows see sunshine, most cows are NOT given hormones, (people give themselves hormones by the way. Every here of birth control pills?) and where exactly do you think "synthetic feed" comes from? We have certainly never had anyone trying to sell us "synthetic feed"! So what makes your statement "true"?!

Michael    
Kansas  |  September, 17, 2013 at 12:33 PM

Great report! Thanks for continuing to expose the rank hypocrisy and incredibly cynical abuses of both farming and low-information, gullible urban consumers for ill-gotten profits by Chipolte. Keep up the good work, and I plan to do my best to encourage a boycott by all urban family and friends, as should all of us.

Leroy Rundhaug    
Wisconsin  |  September, 17, 2013 at 02:50 PM

Mr.Olar: Lasoloacid,Bovine Somatatrophine,Lutalyse ,Estrumate Gonadorelin,Oxytosin,. These hormones immediately come to my mind and are commonly used and prescribed in the dairy industry. A synthetic feed is any feed that is not of natural origin. The only definition of "natural" that matters is the consumers. Cows are now confined to freestall barns especially if the dairy has limited acreage, no sun or freshgrass. I'll take you for a short drive and show you many dairys where this happens. I am also a small dairyman and the issue is our image and consumer perception.(See how easy it is to spin what we do?) As animal caregivers we keep our animals clean ,dry and comfortable. We do it because it's humane first and profitable second.

Steve Savage    
Encinitas, California  |  September, 17, 2013 at 04:01 PM

If a company or a brand has to demonize and/or lie about its competition to sell its product, it reveals something very negative about that company's products or about the character of the people involved. In many other contexts something like this Chipotle add would be considered "hate speech." Why is that "ok" here?

Jafafa Hots    
Ca  |  September, 17, 2013 at 11:21 PM

The "Center for Consumer Freedom" doesn't like it? Such a surprise that this Orwellian-named lobbying agency founded by Philip-Morris to fight anti-tobacco laws and which represents Tyson, Wendy's, Arby's in fighting pro-consumer food legislation. The group whose spokesman John Doyle named as "enemies" "just about every consumer and environmental group, chef, legislator or doctor who raises objections to things like pesticide use, genetic engineering of crops or antibiotic use in beef and poultry." Gosh. The misleadingly-named industry lobbying group created to defend tobacco and specifically tasked with defending the products and practices criticized in this video doesn't like it. Startling.

Jafafa Hots    
Ca  |  September, 17, 2013 at 11:24 PM

Hate speech? Criticizing a product is hate speech somewhere? Oh yeah, I just remembered where - in the "product disparagement" laws the beef industry was instrumental in getting passed. Because products have FEELINGS that can be hurt. Beef was sad from the stigma of being called "fatty."

Mark    
IL  |  December, 23, 2013 at 05:25 PM

Leroy, Get away from all that asphalt & concrete, Go visit a Dairy farm, Beef Farm, Hog Farm. Go to a Farm. Learn something that is Truthful about a farm. Not hearsay, I've raised organic pork (outdoors) & modern production. Why did my client base dry up for organic meat. COST ! & Humanely raised. Make sure you visit in the winter when it's 10 below zero. You tell me what is humane treatment. Maybe you should buy a farm & make it work. I will accuse you of injecting your animals. Sometimes bringing animals indoors is the HUMANE WAY ! By the way , Tried selling organic for 30 years, Never again. I don't treat my modern productions method any different than organic. They go to market 30 days faster on 25% less feed. That's raising them humanely. Less treated (sick) animals.


Ag-Bag MX1012 Commercial Silage Bagger

"The Ag-Bag MX1012 Commercial Silage Bagger is an ideal engine driven mid-size bagger, designed to serve the 150 to 750 ... Read More

View all Products in this segment

View All Buyers Guides