Are Activists Winning?

Activist groups have been haunting production agriculture for decades. I remember how the livestock industry shuddered at the first undercover video. About 10 years ago I spent a long, long Labor Day weekend helping a company overcome an undercover video shot at a poultry operation.

Back then we all hoped activist organizations would eventually dry up and go away. The ag industry didn’t know how to handle these organizations at first—“throw our science at them” we said—but over the years we’ve learned how to communicate more effectively and a significant amount of progress has been made. There is more empathy in our communications with consumers, our tone is less condescending.

Regardless of real or perceived success, activists haven’t gone away. It’s not because the issues have been resolved, it’s because business is just too good.

Unknowing consumers fork over millions of dollars to activists groups every year. For example, take a look at Mercy for Animals (MFA). Their 2017 financials show an income near $13.2 million.  Compare that to 2011 when total revenue was listed at $1.6 million, and you realize that business has been good and getting stronger.

If you want to know what impact $13.2 million can have, I suggest you take a look at the 2017 MFA Annual Report. You can find it here. While MFA determines their own impact, the effect the organization has on shaping the view of animal agriculture in the minds of some consumers is significant.

Unfortunately MFA is just one organization. There are many more, smaller and larger, like it. Agriculture continues to fight an ongoing and often uphill battle. And in many ways animal activist have already won.

Take a look at some of the advancements in animal care in our own industry. We’ve banned tail docking. Dehorning needs to be done with pain remediation. Antibiotics are under strict regulation. There are guidelines on handling downed animals. These requirements and more are part of the National Farmers Assuring Responsible Management (FARM) program.

All of these changes have been for the better. Do you think they would have happened without pressure from activists? We can say that they came in response to consumer demand, but where do you think consumer demand came from?

There are environmental activists as well, many of which are local organizations that oppose large animal operations. A group of such activists recently won a lawsuit against Smithfield Foods around odor originating on hog operations. The first price tag was $50 million, it’s been whittled down to $2.5 million. Still, that group won and now there is precedent for more such lawsuits.

A dairy in Wisconsin is under fire by local activists groups. Pinnacle Dairy is going up south of Madison, Wis., and its faced pressure from environmental organizations every step of the way. The dairy is progressing, but it’s been slow and laborious. (Incidentally, here’s a great, balanced article on the topic.)

There are a number of causes and charities that are worth supporting. Those that help children, fight disease, or help right a wrong top the list and deserve all of the donations of money and time that people can give.

I’m even all for some of the organizations that support animal rights. I think humane shelters are great and worthy institutions. Rescue organizations that save pets from bad environments deserve all the support they can get. 

But some organizations that appear altruistic are really in it for the money. Unfortunately those are the ones that continue to win consumer hearts and minds.

What do you think? Are activists winning? Do you have a story to share about an experience with activist groups? Send me a note at mopperman@farmjournal.com

 

Comments

Restricted HTML

  • Allowed HTML tags: <em> <strong> <cite> <blockquote cite> <ul type> <ol start type> <li> <dl> <dt> <dd> <h2 id> <h3 id> <h4 id>
  • Lines and paragraphs break automatically.
  • Web page addresses and email addresses turn into links automatically.
1 + 4 =
Solve this simple math problem and enter the result. E.g. for 1+3, enter 4.
Submitted by Ty Savoy on Sat, 05/12/2018 - 09:10

All organizations need money to advance their goals. Given the choice between supporting ones that makes money by killing animals, and ones that see needless suffering and death as the evils they are, I know which ones I'd choose to support.

The animal rights ideas are winning. Why ? because from any objective view, nonhuman animals suffer like us human ones do. People can see that. And they don't wish to die for things no one needs, like we do not wish to die. Please stop killing them for a living.

Submitted by Olivia Smith on Thu, 05/17/2018 - 05:06

According the lifestyle will be carrying there and the culture thinking to adopt, remember to own that wardrobe which indulges all those styles the entire globe nature assumes for. Try to remove clutter; whether gift it to someone, sell out or remove from wardrobe. More info visit: https://www.assureshifting.in/packers-and-movers-mumbai/

Submitted by Lucy Gray on Fri, 05/18/2018 - 23:51

Quicken Technical Support Phone Number +1888-336-0774 has many functions that most Mac customers will never use anyway, but the issue of interest to us is, does it have the options needed by Mac Online marketers? I think it does. Speed up allows the production of several records, income and cost monitoring, classification, and all the additional functions you need for tax reasons. Quicken Support Phone Number +1888-336-0774 has the advantages of being a long-running application managed by a well-established company, Intuit, although even it has lately had some economical shakeups (Intuit purchased Great.com and set up its creator and CEO as the new VP and gm. of Intuit's personal fund group).
More Info Visit Website: http://www.quicken.technical-supportnumber.com/

Submitted by Lucy Gray on Fri, 05/18/2018 - 23:51

QuickBooks Tech Support Phone Number+1888-336-0774 Assistance Variety has combined out its Cellphone support for all its manufacturers though the clients can use have found the Speed up and Pay-roll phone include the most helpful. For Speed up, the clients can use can contact at +1888-336-0774. While for its payroll support, the clients can use can use the amount QuickBooks Tech Support Phone Number +1888-336-0774. But on- contact support is available only during Monday to Friday between 6 am-6 pm (PST).
More Info Visit Website: http://www.quickbooks.technical-supportnumber.com/

Submitted by Lucy Gray on Sat, 05/19/2018 - 00:04

You can also assessment your loan provider arrangements. Have you always compensated your information on time? Sage Tech Support Phone Number +1888-336-0774 if so, you need to try to pay better circumstances with these suppliers. Either try for reduced expenses or a greater timespan circumstances to pay as either will improve your main point here.Bank managers often fear meeting little organization entrepreneurs or entrepreneurs. As an idea, they often have great ideas but their information is usually disorganized to say the least. Think about your standard financial institution manager's experience when you appear with your Sage immediate information on your laptop. Before you choose any Sage information application Sage Technical Support Phone Number +1888-336-0774 please take a short while to study more of my FREE recommendations which could aid the protection of the costly mistake of purchasing the incorrect program for your little organization bookkeeping.
More Info Visit Website: http://www.sage.technical-supportnumber.com/

Submitted by anjilo smith on Sat, 05/19/2018 - 01:04

QuickBooks Support Phone Number +1-888-307-3506
Some companies want to songs various technical or help problems with clients. With QuickBooks technique CRM, the payments may be designed in approach (and sent to QuickBooks), however the exclusive problems, who was sent to the case, popularity, concern, and feedback are all managed in technique. Once more, the dash panel and statistics can help become aware of stress areas in addition to a success solution.
http://quickbookstech.supportphone-number.com/

Submitted by anjilo smith on Sat, 05/19/2018 - 01:13

Quicken Support Number +1-888-307-3506
Given that most small business owners usually does not have all that accounting expertise, it is important to know if the item can go as lay-man as it can get and yet will still be efficient when it comes to its purpose of fund monitoring. There are also those that provide an effort edition of the application which can be easily downloadable. From here, we can see a brief yet obvious demonstration of what your small business accounting application can do.
http://quickentech.supportphone-number.com/

Submitted by anjilo smith on Sat, 05/19/2018 - 01:40

Sage Tech Support Number +1-888-307-3506
Sage accounting programs are so commonly used; most customers also appreciate the Support that it gives. If you are going to buy from the company straight, you can make use of their online Sage accounting software assistance. On their website, there are several methods to contact the Sage accounting software employees in case of any concerns or give your Support need when using the application.
http://sagetech.supportphone-number.com/