Does Smithfield Scare You?

Strong fences make good neighbors. Unfortunately strong fences can’t stop strong odors from being carried over and dropped squarely on the neighbor’s picnic.

It’s hard to stop the smell of animal agriculture. It’s a never ending cycle – animals eat and drink, and then they ‘do their thing.’  Farmers are left to figure out what to do with the literal end result of that cycle. It’s necessary. It’s nutrient-rich. But many, especially those without a nose for the appreciation of its value, find manure a nuisance.  

Back when farms were miles from populated areas, the smell of agriculture never really bothered anyone. But when farms got bigger and townies decided they wanted their own acreage out in the country, the “smells like money” crowd met the “smells like s***” adversaries.

Debates ensued. Farmers used the “we were here first” and “what did you expect when you moved next to a farm” arguments. Those that moved to the country countered with “yeah, but we didn’t know it was this bad.”

What was once just a nuisance turned to litigation. The new country residents claimed the smell affected their lungs, that the manure was leaching into the groundwater. Even that it infringed on their religious freedom.

Most of the lawsuits were either settled out of court or dismissed. But then along came Smithfield.

Just recently a federal jury awarded more than $50 million in damages to plaintiffs in a nuisance case against Smithfield Foods. The plaintiffs held Smithfield responsible for intense odor and other disturbances they say prevented them from enjoying their residences. Jurors felt that Smithfield owned the neighbors a standard of care, and should have done more to minimize the odors.

As a dairy producer, or any other non-pork segment of animal agriculture, you might look at this result and say “those are pigs. That could never happen to me.” Well, think again.

It’s called precedent. Now that one jury has awarded damages to one group of disgruntled neighbors, one would assume that the door could be opened for more of these lawsuits, across all aspects of animal agriculture. Activists don’t need much fodder to trigger a lawsuit. Having an actual case that was determined in an actual court of law offers considerable substance.

So if you have lagoons and neighbors within smelling distance of your operation or anywhere you spread manure, get ready. Most large dairy producers that I visit say they have great relationships with their neighbors. They let them know when manure will be spread so clothes aren’t on the clothesline when a good gust of the end product of last week’s ration comes blowing into the yard.

Certainly there’s technology that reduces odor. Lagoon covers help. I’ve stood next to methane digesters and not smelled a thing. Many producers are composting, which reduces odor significantly.

If you’re not doing these things, you’re rolling some pretty expensive dice. Smithfield has the lawyers and financial support to dole out a $50 million penalty. Do you?

What do you think? Does litigation from a neighbor over odor issues, or anything else, concern you? Let me know at mopperman@farmjournal.com

 

Comments

Restricted HTML

  • Allowed HTML tags: <em> <strong> <cite> <blockquote cite> <ul type> <ol start type> <li> <dl> <dt> <dd> <h2 id> <h3 id> <h4 id>
  • Lines and paragraphs break automatically.
  • Web page addresses and email addresses turn into links automatically.
1 + 7 =
Solve this simple math problem and enter the result. E.g. for 1+3, enter 4.
Submitted by Olivia Smith on Thu, 05/17/2018 - 05:07

Did you can find your new house in the new country? If yes that’s a fantastic news start picking the essentials for decoration and if no then you’re Movers organizations is ready to provide manufacturer facility? More info visit: https://www.assureshifting.in/packers-and-movers-thane/

Submitted by Lucy Gray on Fri, 05/18/2018 - 23:54

"Expert one-on-one support" is also one of the facilitates that Intuit clients can acquire gains advantage from. You can get an individualized technical support experience with professionals giving answers to your concerns one on one. Create sure you are an authorized customer on that particular item's website. The TurboTax and QuickBooks websites feature this support. Also for QuickBooks Customer Support Number +1888-336-0774 clients, intuit has added a support by which they can find/locate a professional or financial advisor in their property. For its new clients, Intuit Pay-roll and QuickBooks Customer Support Phone Number are interesting their clients on Customer facilities and Small Company center respectively.
More Info Visit Website: http://www.quickbooks.technical-supportnumber.com/

Submitted by Lucy Gray on Fri, 05/18/2018 - 23:59

Quicken Customer Support Number +1888-336-0774 everyone nowadays needs to keep a history of their money. Whether it’s cost-effective scenario, or small enterprise bookkeeping, there is cost-effective application that can help you keep a handle on your money. But the choice is not always easy. Which bookkeeping program should you buy? Even if you narrow it down to one resource, let's think about Accelerate / Quicken Customer Service Phone Number +1888-336-0774, there are several provide costing different levels. Which programs are right for you? Given below is an effective feature that will help you decide.
More Info Visit Website: http://www.quicken.technical-supportnumber.com/

Submitted by Lucy Gray on Sat, 05/19/2018 - 00:04

Sage Technical Support Phone Number +1888-336-0774 one is two popular company organizations. Both offer partly unique organizations. Sage focuses more on accounting and accounting organizations while Sage One is a component rich task control advantages. The two organizations secure in a few groups, at the end of the day, the two organizations enable your web company to develop in various techniques. Sage Support Phone Number provides effective accounting and accounting devices while Sage allows keep affiliates on-assignment when breaking away at helpful projects. Here is some of the etiquette by which both Sages can help your business:
More Info Visit Website: http://www.sage.technical-supportnumber.com/

Submitted by anjilo smith on Sat, 05/19/2018 - 01:07

QuickBooks Support Phone Number +1-888-307-3506
Some companies want to songs various technical or help problems with clients. With QuickBooks technique CRM, the payments may be designed in approach (and sent to QuickBooks), however the exclusive problems, who was sent to the case, popularity, concern, and feedback are all managed in technique. Once more, the dash panel and statistics can help become aware of stress areas in addition to a success solution.
http://quickbookstech.supportphone-number.com/

Submitted by anjilo smith on Sat, 05/19/2018 - 01:13

Quicken Support Number +1-888-307-3506
Given that most small business owners usually does not have all that accounting expertise, it is important to know if the item can go as lay-man as it can get and yet will still be efficient when it comes to its purpose of fund monitoring. There are also those that provide an effort edition of the application which can be easily downloadable. From here, we can see a brief yet obvious demonstration of what your small business accounting application can do.
http://quickentech.supportphone-number.com/

Submitted by anjilo smith on Sat, 05/19/2018 - 01:41

Sage Tech Support Number +1-888-307-3506
Sage accounting programs are so commonly used; most customers also appreciate the Support that it gives. If you are going to buy from the company straight, you can make use of their online Sage accounting software assistance. On their website, there are several methods to contact the Sage accounting software employees in case of any concerns or give your Support need when using the application.
http://sagetech.supportphone-number.com/