‘Meat’ By Any Other Name

Ingrid Newkirk tries to manipulate words to benefit PETA's agenda. ( Wikipedia )

In the Missouri legislature, a bill that was introduced this session by Rep. Jeff Knight, a Republican representing District 129 in the central part of the state, about 180 miles southwest of St. Louis.

Knight’s proposed bill would prohibit the labeling of food products as “meat” that are not, in fact, meat. It’s obviously aimed at the slew of plant-based, alt-meat analogs that have entered commercial channels labeled as beef, pork or chicken.

According to the Missouri House of Representatives’ website, Knight’s bill is represented as legislation that “Prohibits misrepresenting a product as meat that is not derived from harvested production livestock or poultry.”

If the bill becomes law, Section 265.494 of the state statutes would be amended as follows (the changes are in bold type, as they appear in the text of the bill):

“No person advertising, offering for sale or selling all or part of a carcass or food shall engage in any misleading or deceptive practices, including:
(7) Misrepresenting the cut, grade, brand or trade name, or weight or measure of any product, or misrepresenting a product as meat that is not derived from harvested production livestock or poultry.

Pretty non-controversial, right?

Not if you’re one of our pals at PETA.

David Perle, PETA’s assistant media manager, responded to a report on that bill by a colleague with a statement from PETA President Ingrid Newkirk.

Without even reading her statement, I could guess most of the points she would make, but in this case, I wasn’t prepared for a citation from the Bible as the counter to a piece of legislation attempting to clarify food products labeling.

But then again, this is PETA we’re talking about.

Along with the usual overblown rhetoric characterizing livestock producers as “environmentally destructive perpetrators of animal abuse and purveyors of ill health,” Newkirk attempted to invoke religion as the basis for her opposition to civil policymaking.

“In biblical times,” Newkirk wrote, “[meat] meant ‘food,’ not ‘flesh.’ ”

Apparently, she’s referring to Genesis 9:3: “Everything that lives and moves about will be food for you. Just as I gave you the green plants, I now give you everything,” which would obviously include meat.

However, that verse seems to indicate that, unlike Newkirk, the Almighty Himself was making a distinction between animal foods and green plants — not lumping them all together as “meat.”

Dictionary Doesn’t Lie
But PETA’s counter-argument to Knight’s bill didn’t rely solely on the Good Book. Oh, no. Newkirk invoked another authority to bolster her case: the Merriam-Webster Dictionary.

That’s right. She claimed that Rep. Knight should not be allowed to use the word “harvest” in the language of his bill, because that term’s definition dates back to 1828 and was originally applied to “apples, corn and other crops.”

Well, I looked up the word “harvest” in the Merriam-Webster Dictionary, and not only does it date the world’s origins back to medieval times — not 1828 — but one of the definitions cited refers specifically to “The quantity of a natural product gathered in a single season; the salmon harvest,” and includes a usage example taken from a March 2018 story in the San Antonio Express-News as follows: “Hunters can … report their harvest directly on the turkey page at www.tpwd.texas.gov/turkey.”

Nice try, Ms. Newkirk, but your attempt to inject etymology into an argument against a bill intended to define food labeling, something the Food Safety and Inspection Service does every week of the year, failed as miserably as your organization’s ongoing efforts to assign the rights and privileges of people to every other member of the animal kingdom.

Of course, PETA has long embraced the philosophy that the ends justify the means, and when you start with the conviction that your cause is of supreme importance, it’s but a small step to believing you have justification to do “whatever’s necessary” to advance your cause — hence the exploitation of near-naked women protestors as a tool to protest the exploitation of animals.

When industry officials or media members dismiss the effectiveness of PETA’s shamelessly over-the-top stunts, they often acknowledge that at least the group’s leaders talk a good game, that they’re clever with the use of language.

In this case, however, even that concession doesn’t apply.

And that’s not just me, that’s the dictionary talking.

Editor’s Note: The opinions in this commentary are those of Dan Murphy, a veteran journalist and commentator.




Restricted HTML

  • Allowed HTML tags: <em> <strong> <cite> <blockquote cite> <ul type> <ol start type> <li> <dl> <dt> <dd> <h2 id> <h3 id> <h4 id>
  • Lines and paragraphs break automatically.
  • Web page addresses and email addresses turn into links automatically.
7 + 5 =
Solve this simple math problem and enter the result. E.g. for 1+3, enter 4.
Submitted by Alison Tyler on Sat, 05/12/2018 - 01:51
Submitted by Isebella on Sat, 05/12/2018 - 01:55

Call support number for technical support on all computer issues. Get instant resolution for all technical concerns via phone. Contact +1-855-999-4377 http://www.callsupportnumber.com/

Submitted by Belkin Tech Support on Fri, 05/18/2018 - 03:40

I needed to thank you for this incredible read!! I unquestionably adored each and every piece of it.
Are you facing the problem with your Belkin? Then Fix you technical issue with Belkin Tech Support. We are providing solutions for all issue related to Belkin like http://belkintechsupport.com/reset-belkin-wireless-router/

Submitted by kirti verma on Tue, 05/22/2018 - 02:00

Every weekend I used to visit this website because of this web page content genuine information. If you are experiencing trouble with wireless router visit Belkin.setup

Submitted by Mary Linda on Thu, 05/24/2018 - 04:23

Quicken software related issues. You can contact us toll-free number +1-855-746-8414.
Quicken Customer Support
Quicken Phone Number
Quicken Customer Service Number
Quicken Support Phone Number

Submitted by Antivirus Support on Fri, 06/08/2018 - 04:21

Antivirus is the main thing that everyone needs to secure his computer from viruses. But many times user face some technical problem which he is not able to solve it self. So for solve we are here. Call on antivirus support number 1-866-606-9282 toll-free.
Panda Antivirus Support,
Avg Antivirus Support,
Avast Antivirus Support,
Kaspersky Antivirus Support,
Webroot Antivirus Support,
Bitdefender Antivirus Support,
Avira Antivirus Support,
Node32 Antivirus Support,
McAfee Antivirus Support,
Trend micro Antivirus Support,
Norton Antivirus Support,
Vipre Antivirus Support

Submitted by macybrown on Mon, 06/11/2018 - 02:37

Superb article, a debt of gratitude is in order for assembling this! This is clearly one awesome post. Much obliged for the profitable data and bits of knowledge you have so given here. https://www.couponstechie.com/promo-codes/bullguard/ Thanks for sharing.

Submitted by Dropbox Support Number on Mon, 06/11/2018 - 02:53

Thanks for nice post.Dropbox is one of the leading brands in the business world which has contributed a lot to the trade and created a better image with a good clientage. In case, you are having any kind of technical issues while using Dropbox then, in that situation you can call Dropbox support number +1-866-606-9282 toll-free.
Visit: http://www.helptechnumber.com/dropbox-support/

Submitted by Norton Support Number on Mon, 06/11/2018 - 06:48

Get immediate and fast solution with our experts whenever you face any technical issue in your Norton antivirus by calling Norton support number +1-866-606-9282 toll-free.
Visit: http://www.helptechnumber.com/norton-antivirus-support

Submitted by Roadlux tires on Thu, 06/21/2018 - 03:50

Roadlux tires are the perfect combination of quality and value. They provide highway stability,
excellent wet and dry traction and puncture resistance.Contact us today to find out what
http://roadluxtire.com is

Submitted by BKI89yfes on Wed, 06/27/2018 - 22:08

Half-court complete,stephen curry shoes the garage 12 factors and 4 rebounds 6 aids, Owen 17 rebounds, 2 assists 1 provides the upper hand slightly. But as knight defeat in the second half, even his / her one-on-one hit his details. In this series, OuWenBen needs certain advantages in counterpoint, such as the finals last year, because season of Christmas battles, with their strong particular fortunes turned.

But today the warriors of the changes, let knights staggered, also let like one-on-one hit Owen curry shoes to obtain the rhythm. Actually, today most likely was clay - Thompson The almighty Owen, although Owen hit a dead when in front of him, but clay height reach or to a certain extent, limits the Owen's attack. In only a few times in the face of single singled out in his Arsenal, although Owen possesses good performance, but also it's hard to come back for a knight.

Whole play, scored 28 points 6 rebounds and 10 assists inside the Treasury, 6 of 11 three-point kd shoes shots. 24 points and 3 rebounds, 3 assists, Owen has scored 17 points in the first half, he scored seven points within the second half. Facing the big four with the mighty, and only Erika Owen in one-on-one acquire garage have chances, but today's garage to do better.

Tag: kyrie irving shoes nike epic react yeezy triple white adidas superstar Shoes michael jordan shoes nike sock racer ultra boost 3.0 kyrie 4 confetti kyrie irving shoes Nike Soccer Cleats lebron 14 air jordan 31 adidas pure boost adidas nmd human race air max 90 nike pg 2 stephen curry shoes kyrie 3 nike roshe run kobe bryant jersey new balance running shoes nike vapormax barbour jackets puma fenty kyrie irving jersey nike vapormax yeezy boost 350 v2 air force 1 jordan retro kd 11 shoes air max 270 soldier 11 nike sb dunk kevin durant jersey puma fenty air jordan shoes adidas rose 6 nike air max 270 paul george shoes puma fenty< curry 5 shoes Lebron soldier 11 puma fenty slides ecco adidas eqt lebron 15 ashes vans sk8 hi adidas boost triple s Shoes curry shoes curry shoes adidas porsche lebron soldier 10 lebron james shoes mizuno running shoes nike huarache curry 2 vibram fivefingers adidas yeezy boost 350 v2 zebra adidas yeezy kyrie 4 kobe bryant shoes ugg 5815 adidas crazy explosive adidas nmd r1 primeknit nmd human race kd shoes curry 4 shoes curry 2 curry 4 Shoes puma rihanna creepers adidas alphabounce calvin klein nike free kyrie shoes adidas terrex nike air presto lebron 15 kobe 11 nmd r1 hand spinner nike epic react adidas nmd womens kyrie irving shoes adidas ultra boost adidas soccer cleats

Submitted by Economics Homework Help Online on Thu, 06/28/2018 - 01:40

John Arnold Is An Academic Writer Of The Dissertation-Guidance. Who Writes Quality Academic Papers For Students To Help Them In Accomplishing Their Goals.
Economics Homework Help Online

Submitted by Installing McAfee computer is slow on Sat, 07/07/2018 - 04:30

Don't you hate it when After Installing McAfee Antivirus computer is slow.
Many People Have Reportedly Said That There computer and Other devices Got
Slow After installing Any Particular Antivirus Or Security Suite.
visit http://antivirussupportlife.blogspot.com/2017/12/after-installing-mcafe…
to fix this issues.

Submitted by Mike Flower on Wed, 07/11/2018 - 04:54



Submitted by Windows 10 Support Toll-free Number on Wed, 07/18/2018 - 02:17

If you have encountered with an error on your windows computer, you can call us now on our toll-free number +1-888-588-4698. Our technicians will find what is the
actual problem causing such errors and fix the same with right approach for quick results and assured fix of the windows problems. for more visit here: