Op Ed: Tackling Canada's Sacred Cows

Farm Journal logo

Martha Hall Findlay, the former Liberal member of Parliament, has done the cause of clear thinking a favour by challenging one of the sacred cows of Canadian politics: the protectionist system that keeps the price of milk, eggs and poultry in this country much higher than it needs to be.

So-called supply management is a subject guaranteed to make eyes glaze over and politicians run for cover. But the fact is it forces Canadian consumers to pay hundreds of dollars a year to subsidize a dwindling number of protected farmers, and penalizes other farmers by undermining Canada's efforts to expand trade in agriculture. The system is long past its sell-by date.

Hall Findlay, a past and possibly future contender for the Liberal leadership, blew the whistle on supply management last week in a research paper pointing out the cost to ordinary families. A family that buys four litres of milk a week, she concluded, pays $300 more a year than it would in the United States. Even worse, low-income people bear a disproportionate share of the cost of keeping milk, egg and poultry prices as much as 300 per cent higher than market levels. Simply put, they spend a bigger share of their income on food.

Hall Findlay is also challenging the conventional political wisdom that the system can't be changed because of the electoral clout of protected farmers. She argues there are only 13 ridings with more than 300 dairy farmers, and even in those areas more farmers stand to gain from expanding agricultural exports.

Still, all three federal parties support supply management. The Liberals, in particular, rushed to the system's defence last week when the Conservative government moved to enter the talks for a new Trans-Pacific trade agreement. Absurdly, they argued it guarantees food safety - as if Canadians were at mortal risk from the hundreds of other imported agricultural products not covered by the system.

Defenders argue that without supply management, Canadian dairy farmers would be crushed by American corporate exporters. They also suggest it would be unfair to devalue the significant investments farmers have made in quotas. But, as Hall Findlay points out, Australia dismantled a very similar system in 2001 and effectively managed these problems.

Canada will come under pressure to ditch supply management as it goes ahead with the Pacific trade talks. But change should come not as a concession to foreigners, but as a sound policy move made in the interests of Canadian consumers.

 

Latest News

APHIS Now Thinks Wild Birds Are to Blame for Highly Pathogenic Avian Influenza's Arrival on Four U.S. Dairies
APHIS Now Thinks Wild Birds Are to Blame for Highly Pathogenic Avian Influenza's Arrival on Four U.S. Dairies

The livestock industry continues to grapple with the first confirmed cases of HPAI in cattle, while federal and state agencies continue to assure consumers there's no concern about the safety of the U.S. milk supply.

Success is All in the Details at Kansas Dairy Development
Success is All in the Details at Kansas Dairy Development

Kansas Dairy Development provides temporary housing for up to 80,000 head of cattle — from a few days old to springers nearly ready to calve. Their formula for success is all in the details.

Skills Survey Reveals U.S. Agriculture & Food Industry Workforce Needs and Gaps
Skills Survey Reveals U.S. Agriculture & Food Industry Workforce Needs and Gaps

U.S. employers report challenges in finding suitable job candidates with work-ready skills to fill open roles in ag. The AgCareers.com U.S. Skills Survey offers insights, data and trends to address skill development.

Built Out of Love: How Two Sisters Created a Super-Fast-Growing Yogurt Company
Built Out of Love: How Two Sisters Created a Super-Fast-Growing Yogurt Company

Travel to the rolling hills of Pennsylvania, and you’ll meet Hayley and Stephanie Painter who not only made the Forbes 30 under 30 list, but have also created one of the fastest growing yogurt company in the U.S.

"Boring" Technology Will Reshape Dairy Over the Next 10 Years
"Boring" Technology Will Reshape Dairy Over the Next 10 Years

Once a technology becomes a boring experience it means it has become proven, well-adopted, and easy to utilize. There are three "boring" technologies silently shaping the industry.

Influential Dairy Leaders Awarded World Dairy Expo Recognition Awards
Influential Dairy Leaders Awarded World Dairy Expo Recognition Awards

World Dairy Expo is delighted to announce the recipients of the 2024 Expo Recognition Awards. These individuals have made remarkable contributions to the dairy industry and their communities.