The U.S. dairy market is going through significant transformations, with emerging trends beginning to surface, according to Terrain dairy analyst Ben Laine. At the heart of these changes is the elevated fat content in U.S. farm milk, which has surpassed the requirements for cheese manufacturing and led to an oversupplied cream market.
Understanding the Surplus: Fat vs. Protein
Recent years have seen a steady climb in the fat content at the farm level due to advancements in cattle genetics and nutrition. While this has improved the quality of milk, it has also resulted in leftover cream that exceeds demand, driving down cream multiples. Particularly in the Western U.S., this surplus has led to reduced prices, reflecting the abundant availability of cream early in the year.
Laine explains on the production level, farmers are achieving higher fat milk outputs, which, when sent to cheese plants, results in surplus cream that must be redirected elsewhere. Cream multiples, a pricing factor relative to butter, have reached historical lows not seen since the 2020 pandemic disruption.
The Role of Butter and its Market Dynamics
Butter has traditionally acted as a buffer, capable of being stored for later use, especially during peak holiday demands. However, the current environment of plentiful cream is pushing down prices, even as butter churns exploit the availability of cheap cream. This scenario raises concerns about whether the cream surplus could transform into a butter surplus, potentially limiting the price escalation we have witnessed in previous years.
Nevertheless, strong butter exports are mitigating these potential downsides. Despite the ongoing surplus, international demand remains robust, cushioning the market from a dramatic downturn in butter prices. Still, the high fat values that have been driving market incentives are unlikely to diminish rapidly.
“So far, we’ve lucked out in the fact that we’ve seen really strong butter exports,” Laine says.
Exports: A Beacon of Opportunity
In fact, amidst domestic challenges, the U.S. dairy export volume — measured in milk solids equivalent (MSE) — grew by 3% in March. This marks the highest monthly export volume since February 2023. The year-on-year surge in butter exports is noteworthy, with March seeing a 171% increase, particularly supported by rising exports to Canada, Saudi Arabia and South Korea.
Mexico also marked a significant increase on the Anhydrous Milk Fat (AMF) side, with exports growing exponentially. These figures reflect a favorable competitive pricing landscape for U.S. butter internationally. If domestic surplus persists, the market may increasingly pivot toward enhancing export programs to manage excess butter and cream — despite the traditional challenges associated with exporting U.S. butter due to international standards.
“You might see a shift in the focus on fat versus protein, however, I think we’re going to still see high component levels at the farm,” Laine shares. “There’s still really strong demand overall for dairy fat. I don’t think that’s changing. I think there’s going to be a little bit of a reshuffling as we manage the surplus cream.”
This ongoing reshuffling in the U.S. dairy market suggests a need to find sustainable solutions for managing surplus cream. While it remains uncertain exactly how these surpluses will be absorbed, continued strong export performance provides a silver lining. The industry may increasingly focus on international markets to maintain a balance, especially as traditional domestic outlets adjust to the evolving supply conditions.
Your Next Read:
A Front Row Seat to the Revolutionary Transformation of Milk Production
