Alfalfa is tough to replace in a dairy ration. It supplies protein and fiber, particularly in diets for early-lactation cows. But when alfalfa prices climb, dairy farms may look for other ways to stretch their forage supply and manage feed costs.
Elizabeth French with USDA’s Dairy Forage Research Center and Barbara Dietrich, a master’s student at UW-Madison, have been looking at whether winter cover crops such as rye and triticale could help. Planted after corn silage harvest, the crops can provide another forage harvest the following spring before alfalfa goes in.
“[Cover crops are] a wonderful opportunity,” French says. “[They can] provide a secondary forage source.”
The findings suggest rye and triticale can supply some of the forage fiber normally provided by alfalfa silage. They aren’t a one-to-one replacement, though. Protein levels were lower than alfalfa, and getting the crops harvested at the right stage took careful management.
Which Cover Crops Work in Rations?
Rye and triticale were the main crops in the trial, but French and Dietrich also wanted to see what happened when they added hairy vetch and camelina to the mix. The four treatments included rye, triticale, a rye mixture with hairy vetch and camelina, and a triticale mixture with hairy vetch and camelina.
Rye and triticale were selected partly because they are more winter-hardy than some other options in the Midwest. Hairy vetch is a legume capable of fixing nitrogen, while camelina is an oilseed crop with flowers that may support bee populations.
“Hairy vetch is a legume and a nitrogen fixer, retaining some of that nitrogen within the soil and improving that soil health,” Dietrich says.
The team also wanted to see whether adding those crops could bring environmental benefits alongside their value as feed.
“It’s tying some more sustainability aspects of using these cover crops, more than just feeding the cow, but how to improve our overall soil health and environment,” Dietrich says.
The crops were planted after corn silage harvest and harvested the following spring, before alfalfa planting. This gave farms another chance to harvest forage from the same fields between their main cropping seasons.
Nutritionists pay close attention to forage neutral detergent fiber (NDF) when balancing rations. NDF is the fibrous portion of a plant, and cows need enough forage fiber to support rumination and rumen function. French says the team wanted to see whether cover crops could supply some of the forage NDF normally provided by alfalfa silage.
“As we look at dairy rations overall, the fundamental aspect of the nutrient that we focus on a lot is forage neutral detergent fiber,” French says. “We know that fundamentally we need a certain amount of forage NDF coming into our dairy rations.”
The team aimed to harvest the crops at the boot stage, targeting crude protein levels between 17% and 20%. However, the mixtures came in closer to 13% to 14%. The alfalfa silage used in the trial was closer to 25% crude protein.
The lower protein levels meant adjusting protein sources in the rations. Ingredients such as canola meal, soybean meal and roasted soybeans helped keep diets similar in crude protein and total NDF while the team evaluated the forage NDF supplied by the cover crops.
Can Cover Crops Lower Dairy Feed Costs?
The trial ran from June through December 2024 and included 80 early-lactation cows. All cows received a control diet through the transition period and their first 21 days in milk. They were then assigned to the control diet or one of the four cover crop diets through about 93 days in milk.
The team tracked milk production, blood metabolites, methane emissions, rumination, body condition and digestibility.
Milk production was numerically highest among cows fed the rye diets, averaging about 118 pounds per day. Cows on the triticale and control diets averaged about 110 pounds, while cows receiving the three-way triticale mixture averaged about 105 pounds.
Although cows fed rye produced the most milk on average, the differences were not statistically significant. The trial did not establish a milk production advantage for rye over the other diets.
Feed costs offered another point of interest. Based on alfalfa hay prices at the time of the analysis, the cover crop rations cost less per cow each day, French says.
“What was really interesting, if we looked at today’s market and some of the prices of alfalfa hay, we actually came out lower in diet costs with our cover crop rations,” she says.
When the team calculated feed cost on an energy-corrected milk basis, however, the triticale and control diets were very similar. Potential savings depend on alfalfa prices and the cost of other ingredients used to balance the ration.
Protein levels also may have affected production. The three-way triticale mixture was lower in metabolizable protein, which French says could have limited milk production.
“If we’re able to increase that in the ration, then we’re able to have that converted into milk in this case,” she says.
French also noted milk urea nitrogen levels in the rye diets averaged close to 14. She says there may have been room to improve protein efficiency or adjust the concentrate portion of the ration.
“I think what this research really demonstrates is that you need that forage NDF in your lactating rations, and cover crops can provide that,” French says.
Harvest Timing Can Affect Forage Quality
Getting rye and triticale harvested at the right stage may be one of the bigger challenges. Rye has a narrow window at the boot stage, Dietrich says, with about 48 hours to hit the desired timing.
The cover crop silages in the trial also were wetter than the team would have liked, creating challenges during ration formulation and feedout.
“We had these great milk yields, but you have to have the correct management with utilizing it,” Dietrich says.
Triticale did not produce the same numerical milk yield as rye, but its energy-corrected milk performance was similar to the control diet. Dietrich says the best use of the forage may depend on its quality and where it fits in a farm’s feeding program.
“If it does go bad, maybe this is something that we can utilize for the heifers or later-lactation cows,” she says. “It’s being able to manipulate having that extra forage. If it’s better quality, then we’ll use it for early lactation or decide what stages of life it’s best used for.”
French says the team is still analyzing NDF digestibility. Early results suggest the cover crops may offer benefits in this area, potentially giving nutritionists more flexibility when balancing forage and concentrate ingredients.
Could Rye and Triticale Work in Heifer and Dry Cow Diets?
Beyond early-lactation cows, French sees potential use in replacement heifer diets. The lower crude protein levels observed in the trial may suit heifers at different stages of development, including before and after breeding.
Far-off dry cows also may be a better fit than close-up cows, depending on the diet’s mineral balance and nutrient requirements.
The team is also evaluating methane and nitrogen utilization. Dietrich says overall methane output did not differ among the treatment diets. Some differences appeared when methane was measured against dry matter intake, but those differences were not present when accounting for factors such as body weight and intake.
Nitrogen utilization analysis is still underway.
French says next steps include testing higher inclusion rates and taking a closer look at harvest timing, along with work on forage storage and preservation. The team also conducted a related trial with mid-lactation cows at a 15% inclusion rate, with more results expected.
Rye and triticale won’t replace alfalfa in a dairy ration, but they may give farms another way to harvest forage between cropping seasons. Whether they help lower feed costs depends on crop performance, harvest management, forage quality and the price of alfalfa.
For more on nutrition, read:
- An Oklahoma Dairy’s Recipe for Lower Feed Costs Starts with Flour
- Sorghum Silage Gains Ground as Water Concerns Push Dairies to Rethink Forage
- High-Oleic Soybeans Offer Energy and a Chance to Cut Feed Costs
- Short-Stature Corn Could Give Dairy Farmers a New Forage Option
- Could Dirty Water Be Part of Your SCC Problem?


