The dairy industry is facing a transformative moment. As Dr. Robert Hagevoort, an associate professor and extension dairy specialist at New Mexico State University highlighted at the Dairy Cattle Reproduction Council (DCRC) Annual Conference in Arlington, Texas, “Talent now has a choice.” This statement encapsulates the shifting dynamics in workforce management within the industry and highlights the need for dairy operations to adapt to this new reality.
The Changing Workforce Landscape
The confluence of retiring baby boomers, low birth rates, evolving immigration policies, and changing worker preferences is creating a significant challenge for U.S. employers, including those in the dairy industry. With fewer workers available to fill open positions, the emphasis has shifted towards not just attracting talent, but also retaining it. As Hagevoort points out, future talent now chooses whether to join and remain with a dairy operation.
This shortage impacts dairy farms across the country, leading to a pressing need to develop talent from within. Hagevoort advocates for a shift from a traditional “hunter and gatherer” approach—where the focus was on hiring external talent—to a “home-grown philosophy.” The question for producers is clear: How much potential talent is going unnoticed or undeveloped within their own operations?
From Cow Managers to People Managers
The paradigm shift in the industry means that farm owners and managers are increasingly tasked with managing people, not just cows. Yet, as Hagevoort notes, many of these managers were trained to be cow operators, not people leaders. The transition requires learning how to recognize, develop and nurture home-grown talent rather than relying solely on external hires.
Hagevoort encourages producers to delve deeply into the capabilities of their current employees. Identifying hidden talents in milkers, for example, could lead to development into feeding or mid-manager roles, enhancing the operational efficiency and morale.
Maximizing Employee Potential
Another crucial concern is the optimization of employee performance. Hagevoort raises an important question about how many hours employees perform at full capacity versus at a diminished level.
“Employees tend to ‘tank’ after 6 hours of work,” he observes, suggesting that employers should consider changing routines or providing better nourishment options to keep employees energized. With many workers relying on energy drinks, there is an opportunity to improve nutrition, which could directly impact productivity and employee well-being.
The Million-Dollar Question
In closing, Dr. Hagevoort challenges producers with a critical question: “How much money is left on the table because employees’ ‘tank’ after six hours of work?”
It’s a call to action for dairy owners to rethink their management strategies and create a workplace that maximizes the return on investment by ensuring employees are contributing at their highest level.
In this era of choice, adapting to these changes is not optional but a necessity. By embracing these strategies, dairy farms can better navigate the challenges of today’s labor market and cultivate a thriving workforce that is both skilled and committed.
Your Next Read:
Stop Thinking of Your Employees as an Assembly Line


