Thoracic Ultrasound Offers Clues to BRD Treatment Outcomes in Dairy Calves

Calves with more severe lung lesions were substantially less likely to achieve resolution following treatment, while early-life serum total protein offered little insight into recovery.

How helpful would it be to look inside live calves to inspect their lung condition? That’s now possible with the same ultrasound technology veterinarians use to diagnose pregnancies.
.
(Maureen Hanson)

A calf’s lung ultrasound score at the time of bovine respiratory disease (BRD) diagnosis may offer veterinarians an early indication of how likely it is to recover. New research involving nearly 1,800 preweaned dairy calves found that the severity of pulmonary lesions was strongly associated with clinical outcomes following antimicrobial treatment.

The study, published in The Bovine Practitioner, found that each one-point increase in calf thoracic ultrasound severity score (CFUS) was associated with a 53% increase in the risk of clinical failure. In contrast, serum total protein (STP) concentrations measured during the first week of life showed no association with subsequent treatment outcomes.

Researchers from The Ohio State University and Dairy Doctors Veterinary Services analyzed calf health records from eight commercial dairy farms in Ohio and Wisconsin. Of the 1,779 calves included in the analysis, 1,200 (67.5%) achieved ultrasound lesion resolution, while 579 (32.5%) experienced clinical failure.

Key Takeaways

  • Each one-point increase in CFUS at diagnosis was associated with a 53% increase in clinical failure risk.
  • Predicted failure probability increased from 20% for calves with a score of 2 to 75% for calves with a score of 5.
  • Calves diagnosed at their second ultrasound examination had 1.5 times the failure risk of those diagnosed at their first examination.
  • Early-life STP concentrations were not associated with clinical failure following BRD diagnosis.

More Severe Lung Lesions, Poorer Outcomes

The difference in outcomes between calves with mild and severe lung lesions was substantial. Researchers estimated that calves with a CFUS of 2 had a 20% probability of clinical failure. That figure climbed to 31% for calves with a score of 3, 49% for a score of 4 and 75% for a score of 5.

The Wisconsin Calf Lung Ultrasound Scoring System classifies findings on a scale from 0 to 5:

  • Score 0: Less than 1 cm of lung consolidation; considered normal.
  • Score 1: Severe, diffuse comet-tail artifacts, which are uncommon in dairy calves and are not classified as BRD.
  • Score 2: Patchy areas of consolidation that combine to exceed 1 cm.
  • Score 3: Lobar pneumonia, with one fully consolidated lung lobe.
  • Score 4: Two consolidated lung lobes.
  • Score 5: More than two consolidated lung lobes.

In the study, calves with scores of 2 or higher were classified as having BRD and received antimicrobial treatment.

The findings give veterinarians another way to use ultrasound examinations beyond identifying calves with respiratory disease. As the authors explain:

“Clinically, a higher ultrasound score at the time of diagnosis is a harbinger of increased clinical failure probability and can assist the veterinarian in managing client expectations, monitoring intensity and rechecking timing.”

When calves were first diagnosed also influenced outcomes. Those identified during their second ultrasound examination had 1.5 times the risk of clinical failure compared with calves diagnosed during their first examination.

The researchers suggest that some calves may have had pulmonary lesions before they were detected, potentially delaying treatment. They note that additional research is needed to better understand the relationship between age at diagnosis and clinical outcomes.

“Overall, the prognostic message is clear: each point higher CFUS at diagnosis increases clinical failure risk by ~53%, whereas STP shows no meaningful association with clinical failure after adjusting for severity,” summarize the authors.

Passive Transfer Status Did Not Predict Recovery

The lack of an association between early-life STP and treatment outcomes offers another perspective on how passive transfer monitoring can inform calf health programs.

STP concentrations were measured within the first week after birth as part of routine passive transfer assessment. Mean values were relatively consistent across ultrasound severity categories, ranging from 6.07 g/dL among calves with a CFUS of 2 to 5.79 g/dL among calves with a score of 5.

“The lack of an association between STP and clinical failure suggests that, within the observed ranges, passive transfer status may be more relevant to disease risk than to treatment response once BRD is established,” caution the authors.

For veterinarians incorporating thoracic ultrasonography into routine calf health evaluations, the findings offer another reason to look beyond simply identifying the presence of lung lesions. The degree of pulmonary consolidation at diagnosis may also help identify calves at greater risk of persistent disease, supporting more targeted monitoring and more informed conversations with producers about expected outcomes. Further research will help clarify how diagnosis timing and follow-up examinations can be incorporated into management decisions.

DHM Logo-Black-CL
Get News Daily
Get Market Alerts
Get News & Markets App